Monday, March 31, 2025

*A Bible Genealogy*

First, I want to give credit and thanks to folks at familysearch.org.  Not only have they been methodically digitizing most of their massive microfilm collections thus making them freely available online, but now they have introduced Experiments run by FamilySearch Labs.  I've been using the Full Text Search experiment for a couple years now, and find it a real game changer.  I think of all the hours I spent at the library trying to even read the indexes, and now poof, machine reading of all of it.  Astounding by itself, but this kind of technology takes research to another level by revealing unindexed names (or other search strings) buried in the texts.

Incredibly, this new Full Text Search has been made available for most if not all of the deeds and probate records for each state, two of the most valuable record groups for finding our ancestors.  From the comfort of my home, all I need to do on a rainy day is play with this new search engine using the names and places I know so well, and quite often I'm able to find a few things I hadn't found before.  Things like a transcription of a genealogy recorded in a bible found in an antique store in Walled Lake, Michigan.  That record has been sitting among the Oakland County films all this time, and I just never found it because my life isn't long enough to pick through every hay stack.....

So now to this recently discovered bible genealogy.  This Gillespie genealogy is included in a collection called "Bible and Family Records of Pioneers of Highland and Hartland Townships, Oakland County, Michigan, Volume 2" indexed and compiled by several chapters of the Michigan DAR in 1957.  I would never have any reason to search in this collection for Gillespies, and yet here was recorded a Gillespie family group:

  • James Gillespie, born 25 Mar 1789
  • Elizabeth Gillespie, born 22 May 1793
  • Mary Ann Gillespie, born 26 May 1812
  • Isabelle Gillespie, born 25 Oct 1813
  • Alexander Gillespie, born 20 Mar 1815
  • Thomas Gillespie, born 8 Jul 1816
  • John Gillespie, born 2 May 1818
  • James Gillespie, born 2 Dec 1819
  • Elizabeth, Gillespie, born 22 Sep 1821

There is also a column to the right of each name listing the age of that person when they died.  

You have to imagine me staring at this family group for quite some time because my brain couldn't quite grasp seeing all these names listed together as a family.  Fifteen years ago I was just discovering my 2nd great granduncle, James H. Gillespie, somebody whose life was glossed over in the Gillespie Family Record written by Edith Gillespie in 1966.  James H. Gillespie married Belle Greer and they ended up spending much of their lives in Colorado where they also died.  When I went to get their death certificates, I learned that Belle Greer's mother was Isabelle Gillespie, a name found nowhere else in my family history.  Thus, many of the early posts in this blog have been about me trying to understand who Isabelle Gillespie was, as well as a handful of other Gillespies in early Oakland County, Michigan who didn't fit into my family history, names that include James, Mary Ann (Sloat), and Thomas.  And now here are all these names in one place.

But do the names in the bible genealogy align with what we know of my mystery Gillespies in early Oakland County?  I believe they do for these reasons:

  • White Lake, where Thomas Gillespie Jr lived, is pretty close to Walled Lake where the bible was found.
  • The birth dates in the bible for Mary Ann, Isabelle, and Thomas are all the exact birth dates found on records or gravestones in Michigan!
  • The death certificates for Mary Ann Gillespie Sloat and Thomas Gillespie both list their father's name as James.
  • The Michigan gravestone for a James Gillespie who died in 1866 at the age of 46 has always been a mystery, but now the bible genealogy has a James Gillespie whose birth year could finally let us know who he was. 
  • When Thomas Gillespie Sr. was declared incompetent in 1855, Henry Sloat, spouse of Mary Ann Gillespie, became Thomas' guardian, and the other interested parties noted in the case were most likely the niece and nephew mentioned:  Isabella Greer and Thomas Gillespie Jr.

And finally, knowing that my Gillespie relations came to Michigan via Orange County, New York, having arrived there around the War of 1812, I have long pondered the 1820 census enumerating a family group of a James Gillespie in Fishkill, NY.  In looking at that census now, the enumeration of that family group fits this bible family group exactly.  Likewise, the 1830 census of James Gillespie in Newburgh, NY could be the same person previously enumerated in Fishkill, although the wife had probably died and James was living with an older daughter as well as the youngest.

So all of this is exciting, but I'm stumped about the death notations in the bible genealogy -- none of the ages listed match the ages determined by known death dates of some the people on this list, specifically Mary Ann, Isabelle, and Thomas.  We have to wonder if there was a transcription mistake, and if not that, then what other explanation for incorrect ages at death?  That's an open question.

Meanwhile, I've been juggling my family tree around trying to understand how two Gillespie brothers, specifically Thomas Gillespie Sr. and James Gillespie of the bible genealogy, can be related to my ancestor, John Gillespie, and the daughters from his first marriage who emigrated from Armagh first to NY and then to MI.  Given the various vital dates, I surmise that my ancestor, John, had a brother, one whose name is currently unknown.  Thomas Gillespie Sr. and James Gillespie of the bible genealogy were sons of my John Gillespie's brother.  Sounds messy when I write about this over 200 years later, but it was actually simple.  Family groups were large and tended to stick together once the decision was made to travel across the world with no idea what lies ahead.

So if this hypothesis is right:

  • Thomas Gillespie Sr. married his first cousin Nancy Gillespie after the death of her first husband, Robert Greer.
  • Isabelle Gillespie married her second cousin, John Greer, John being the son of James Greer and Jane Gillespie, daughter of my John Gillespie.
  • When James H. Gillespie married Belle Greer, he was marrying his 1/2 first cousin once removed.
And because of all these tangled connections, it's easier to understand why tracing any DNA matches that might be related to these lines has been next to impossible!

Obviously, there are always more questions, and clearly my educated speculation about the true relationships between all these people means that I might stand to be corrected at some point down the road.  But even the slightest clarity arriving no matter how many years after the impossible questions were posed is a welcome gift.  The name of Isabelle Gillespie has been a brick wall standing for many years, one that has existed only because of how little we actually know about the big picture of the families surrounding each ancestor.  Now, Isabelle has a family group and her connection to my family group is assumed by virtue of having shared her life so closely with those of my Michigan pioneers.

All thanks to machine learning.  I think Aunt Edith is shaking her head in wonder and delight.



Thursday, March 21, 2024

Gillespie Riddle

Over the years, I've seen any number of Gillespie family trees that point to the couple, James Gillespie and Elizabeth Riddle, as the progenitors of their family line.  I eventually found one source which is probably responsible for this claim:  American Ancestry (AA), which is itself an unsourced work of many volumes claiming to register the pedigrees of early American males.  Volume 11 has an entry for Gillespie which runs for several pages, starting with brothers David, John, and James who descended from the Campbell clan in the highlands of Scotland and later crossed into Ireland to first settle in county Antrim.  After fighting for the Prince of Orange in 1690, the Gillespie brothers moved to county Monaghan where James Gillespie married Elizabeth Riddle around 1700 and from there, the story of all their descendants flows.  How I would love to know who was the author of this account.

As we know, the problem with these sorts of publications is their tale usually cannot be corroborated and yet they often contain some nugget of truth.  Some of the details almost fit what many of us know about our Gillespies, but not quite, no matter how much we want them to.  And for each unsubstantiated claim used as the precursor for the next unsubstantiated claim, the value of such sources shrinks into a sad curse befalling many family historians — to innocently believe in our own blindness. 

The good news is this:  even though some things get lost with the passage of time, other things, remarkably, get found.  Given that we're talking here about Ireland where so much family history was consumed by flames, any evidence "found" these days comes as a surprise.  And so, such a moment recently presented itself to me:

According to a marriage contract recorded on 19 Nov 1725, Andrew Rutherford of Caddagh and William Riddle of Annaghmacneal, both of Tullycorbet parish, co Monaghan acknowledged themselves to be indebted to James Gillespie of Derryvalley for 50 pounds on condition that he marry Elizabeth Riddle, daughter of John Riddle, deceased, of Tynascamphy (?); Rutherford and Riddle to turn over lease from Michael Fleming of 990 years for 40 acres in Mullacrock, Tullycorbet, several witnesses including David Gillespie of Drummuck, linen draper.

This contract was recorded as memorial 151382 in volume 228, page 405, part of memorial books going back to 1709 which are stored in the Registry of Deeds in Dublin.  We can thank the Genealogical Society of Utah for creating 2686 microfilms of the memorial books in 1951, and the Family History Library for since digitizing those films so they are viewable online today.  We can also thank countless volunteers who contribute to the efforts to index and transcribe these memorials, and in the case of this particular memorial, my personal thanks go to researcher Sharon Oddie Brown. 

There might well be other memorials pertaining to James and Elizabeth, which might see the light of day if another hard-working soul locates, indexes, transcribes, and publishes them.  Meanwhile, there a number of other memorials pertaining to Gillespies in Tullycorbet parish of county Monaghan.  In particular, we learn from them about one Bothwick Gillespie, who was mentioned at the end of the AA account as a son of Joseph Gillespie and who sailed for America after the Rebellion of 1798.  But now the memorials tell us that David Gillespie of Drummuck had a son named Bothwick, and even more astonishingly, on 9 Sep 1795, Bothwick Gillespie of North Carolina in the United States of America conveyed his lands back in Drummuck to John Coulter.  See how the memorials shed new light on the details from the AA account?  And see how one particular memorial now clearly associates Gillespies in North Carolina with Gillespies in Drummuck, Monaghan.  Happily, that which has been blurred becomes focused through the lens of real evidence.  

Maybe it's coincidence that I decided to start the new year by digging into Gillespies in County Monaghan (click here to see my research notes).  And now surprise, we have stumbled into some clearly identifiable Gillespie family groups in Tullycorbet parish, Monaghan.  The question of whether they are related to my Gillespie family is open, although it seems very likely that all Gillespies in that region of Eastern Monaghan-Western Armagh probably knew of each other, related or not.  

For the moment, it's just good to feel that my own Research Going Nowhere can still be revitalized.  All us family history researchers can use the reminder that new discoveries leading to new understandings are still and always completely possible.


Tuesday, March 29, 2022

*The Kinship of Neighbors and Friends*

Historically speaking, the Hossack connection to the Gillespie family appears to have been more than just as a passing acquaintance. 

In early Quebec, a wholesale grocer company was formed called Hossack and Woods, or Hossack Woods & Co.  The Woods part of this company relates to our Woods family, nephews of my gggg-grandmother, Jane Woods, who was the second wife of our progenitor, John Gillespie.  This Woods-Hossack connection is further highlighted in the name of James Hossack Bert Woods, 1867-1941, son of Alexander Woods and Elizabeth Banfield.

The Gillespies and the Hossacks were neighbors along the St. Charles river at Little River, Quebec (Petite Riviere is the little river St. Charles flowing into the St. Lawrence from the north and the west just below Quebec City).  The Gillespies rented from the Hossacks for awhile, and then James Gillespie helped to restore the Hossack family home in later years.  Many letters between Gillespies and Hossacks who lived in Quebec and Michigan have survived.  

Research into the Hossack family who were Gillespie neighbors in Quebec has lead back to Moray, Scotland and a search among DNA matches of several Gillespie testers has revealed at least one small match to Hossacks of Moray. But I also found DNA matches who trace back to a Hosick family in Markethill as well as a Hozack family in Mullaghbrack, Armagh, close to where our Gillespie family group last lived in Northern Ireland. Were any or all of these families somehow related to Gillespies before becoming neighbors in Quebec?

Whether Hossacks are blood relations to the Gillespies is probably only relevant (to me) if the two families came from the same area of Scotland. But perhaps the two families were "only" neighbors and friends.  I am reminded of the number of people in my life to whom I am not blood-related but who are, for all that matters, my family. Such people often alter the course of our lives for the better and without them the quality of life would be far less bright.  It makes me wish DNA could measure love and connection as well as biology.

Monday, March 28, 2022

*Jamieson Matches*

 In 1835, my ancestor James Gillespie married Mary Jamieson in Lisnadill parish, Armagh.  Shortly after, they emigrated to Quebec where they raised their family and spent the rest of their lives.  According to the recorded memories of their daughter, Mary Gillespie Henderson, (Memories of my early years, 1937 Montreal, pp 9-10), we know that Mary was one of four daughters of Arthur Jamieson and Mary Orr, and she had two brothers, John and William, who also emigrated to Quebec.  Arthur Jamison was recorded in the Griffith's Valuation of Ballymoran in Lisnadill, Armagh in 1864, and he died in 1866 at the age of 73.

Thanks to DNA matching, we are beginning to expand our knowing of the Jamieson family.  We now have matches leading to descendants of John Jamieson and Eliza Ferguson (Ontario, Canada), Ann "Nancy" Jamieson and James Diffin (Ontario, Canada), and Eliza Jamieson and Andrew Keys (Northern Ireland).  The Jamiesons are also thought to have originated from Scotland, so we also have them to thank for our Celtic ancestry.  

Saturday, December 18, 2021

Year in Review

This year I discovered DNA Painter, and have been busy building a chromosome map for myself. The hope is to identify the chromosomes and segments that pertain to my Gillespie clan, and knowing that, associate other testers on the same chromosome/segments whose relationship is currently unknown but whose stories might provide new clues and new links that lead to our Scotland connection. In the course of this venture, I was able to connect with a number of Gillespie elders both in U.S. and Canada who were willing to participate. The chromosome map is beginning to fill in! Finding more testers to participate is a challenge, but every year brings more unexpected advances. 

Here are few other research highlights for the year: 
  • Because of a match on FTDNA, I made contact with Glenyss G. who descends from Thomas Gillespie of Cavanacaw, and is a current resident of Northern Ireland. It's very exciting to make contact with a living Gillespie relation still in Northern Ireland. Unfortunately, her family history reveals no more prior to Thomas Gillespie. And because Thomas Gillespie was the son of John Gillespie's first marriage, the fact that we can identify any DNA match with this branch is somewhat of a miracle. 
  •  I spent a fair amount of time researching COLL/COYLE family groups who emigrated from County Donegal before the US Civil War and settled in the Pittsburgh area. Multiple members from this family group are DNA matches to known Gillespie testers. The rub is that these families were heavily Catholic, and Donegal is nowhere near Armagh. Still in all, a study of the Griffith's Valuation shows that a surprising number of Gillespie households were found in Donegal. So somehow we share DNA with Catholic Gillespies from Donegal! 
  • I explored the life of John Gillespie, born around 1830 in Donegal, according to his Civil War enlistment records. He arrived in the U.S. in the early 1850s where he married Sarah McElhose. He was a blacksmith, and settled in Port Byron, IL. More DNA connections with no answer. 
  • I explored the life of Capt. James Gillespie, 1774-1868, a sailor and ship's master who lived in Portpatrick, Wigtownshire, Scotland, just a skip across the Irish Sea to Northern Ireland. His descendants emigrated to Montreal around 1835 and then settled in Ontario, and later the northwest territories where many of their DNA testers live today. How connected to us? 
  • I explored the life of Margaret Gillespie, ~1849-1945, who married Francis Waterson and then moved to Dunedin, New Zealand where descendants still live today. Margaret was the daughter of John Gillespie and Margaret Cameron who married in Glasgow in 1838. John is thought to have been the son of George Gillespie and Agnes Campbell who lived in Paisely. 
  • Finally, I explored the lives Maggie and Minnie Gillespie, both born in the late 1860s in Armagh with a father named Thomas. I suspect these were daughters of Thomas Gillespie and Sarah Woods, and granddaughters of Thomas Gillespie of Cavanacaw and his wife Margaret Johnston. These daughters made their way to Lancashire, England, also just across the Irish Sea, where they worked as servants. Maggie eventually married, and her descendants still live in the same area of the UK. 
  • And for those who know that in 2019-2020 I took a deep dive into Gillespie research in early Ulster and Orange counties, New York, a handful of DNA matches have since surfaced to some of those early American (pre-Revolution) families. The connection still eludes us but it is there. 
And so the beat goes on. For 2022, I'm considering giving up the notion of being frustrated that we're still poking around in the darkness with little reason to think the cave of the past holds answers. But just look at all these stories about Gillespies with whom I share some DNA!  It's like looking into the night sky that twinkles just on the edge of our comprehension — there's always more to learn.  In a continuing world of pandemic restrictions, I find comfort in imagining the fullness of our Gillespie ancestors' lives — how we got here and how we shall carry on.  And so we shall.

Friday, June 26, 2020

Scotland Saints

More of my posts these days are to report on small DNA matches to me who also have GILLESPIE in their family tree. No matter how small the DNA match, I check what I can of the match's family tree to see where the Gillespie name might fit in. Even though I have yet to confirm with genealogical proof that the Gillespie surname is the source of the DNA matches I mention here, these slim matches have nevertheless lead to some unexpected, interesting, and even amazing stories. Here is yet another.

This story starts in 1820 in western New York with a man named Joseph Smith. Smith had a religious vision that lead to the establishment of a new American church in 1830, one called Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, and known by the public as Mormonism. By 1838, two native Scots living in Ontario, Canada, converted to the new religion, which they then introduced to Scotland on a trip back to visit family. They began preaching in Glasgow in 1840, and one decade later, several thousand Scots had joined the new religion.

Now for the Gillespie matches. The family trees of two small DNA matches to me trace back to Robert Easton (b 1751) and Ann Gillespie (b 1760). This couple apparently lived in New Monkland, Lanark, Scotland, an area 11 miles northeast of Glasgow and part of a municipal burgh called Airdrie. Large beds of coal and ironstone were mined from this area throughout the 19th Century. Here is one description of nearby Coatbridge in the 1840s:

"There is no worse place out of hell than that neighbourhood. At night, the groups of blast furnaces on all sides might be imagined to be blazing volcanoes at most of which smelting is continued on Sundays and weekdays, day and night, without intermission. From the town comes a continual row of heavy machinery: this and the pounding of many steam hammers seemed to make even the very ground vibrate under one's feet. Fire, smoke and soot with the roar and rattle of machinery are its leading characteristics; the flames of its furnaces cast on the midnight sky a glow as if of some vast conflagration. Dense clouds of black smoke roll over it incessantly and impart to all the buildings a peculiarly dingy aspect. A coat of black dust overlies everything."

Robert Easton and Ann Gillespie had a son, Robert Easton, Jr., born in 1796. In 1814, Robert Jr. married Elizabeth Laird, and they had 10 children before Robert Sr. died in 1849. According to the 1841 Census of Scotland, his occupation had been in the coal mines.

Now comes the amazing part, or the beginning of it. On 2 Mar 1850, a ship called Hartley sailed from Liverpool with 109 Latter-Day Saints on board, including Elizabeth Easton and two of her children. On 2 May 1850, the ship arrived in New Orleans where the passengers then traveled up the Mississippi River to St. Louis. There they met other of Elizabeth's children who had departed for America earlier. The family worked in coal mines as they had in Scotland until they had what they needed for the trip west to establish Zion. They traveled on what is now called the Mormon Pioneer Trail, which extended 1300 miles from Nauvoo, IL, to the Salt Lake Valley in Utah.  Some of the Eastons settled in Utah, and others continued to California.  Elizabeth Easton died in Gilroy, Santa Clara, CA in 1860 at the home of her son, George -- over 5000 miles from the coal mines of Monkland, Lanark, Scotland.

So for all my wondering about the religious associations of our Gillespie clan, we have never considered that a faith started in America might have also contributed to Gillespie migration away from Scotland. But maybe converting to Mormonism was more about existing religions of the time giving little help or hope to those living in poverty and despair, while a faraway vision espoused the idea that earnest goodness was enough to recognize simple people as saints. Whatever the true impetus for launching such a remarkable journey, the power of believing in something better had everything to do with finding Gillespie DNA traces among LDS descendants today.

Reflecting on this story gives me pause in our own trying times. With or without theology, what is it that inspires us to endure the worst and believe in the best, to reach beyond ourselves and our circumstances into the unknown? If the only promise of life is that being alive makes a difference, then the ancestors embraced that promise with their own determination. I want to be in that number.

Friday, June 19, 2020

Juneteenth

This post comes about because of a faint DNA match between me with 0% African ethnicity and somebody with 75% African ethnicity. Her family tree points to a direct ancestor named Gillespie, and while the reason for the match between us might not relate to that surname, the story I am uncovering is beside the point of how we are related. This story is about all of us, and for that reason, the story deserves much more detail than I can put in this blog post. But today is one of those days, and I want to talk about it.

This story is set in Wayne County, Kentucky in the 1800s, in the years surrounding and including the American Civil War, 1861-1865, which still stands as America's bloodiest conflict. Kentucky was a border state between the North and the South and when the War Between the States broke out, the KY governor issued a proclamation of neutrality in the spring of 1861. But a shadow government favoring KY secession was formed, which then was accepted by the Confederacy in Dec. 1861 as the 13th Confederate state.

The dual governments in KY caused many family divisions with some sons fighting for the North and some for the South. About 100,000 Kentuckians served for the Union, and between 25,000-40,000 for the Confederacy.  In January 1862, the Confederates were defeated in the Battle of Mill Springs, which is geographically at the heart of the story being told here. 164 souls died there that day, another 611 were wounded or missing.

And now to the Gillespies. From my research, two Gillespies, James and Robert, both white, came to Wayne County just before 1820. They may have come from either VA or NC, and why they settled in Wayne is unknown. Based on a study of the records, I surmise that James and Robert were probably brothers, or they were otherwise closely related.

Robert Gillespie had a son named William, 1808-1855, who married the daughter of James Cowan, Nancy. This William Gillespie left a will which named the slaves apparently in his possession at that time:
  • Perry & his wife Rebecca, and their children Isaac and William
  • Rose & her son Louis
  • Lucinda & her child Green (?)
William's will stated that these slaves should go equally to his sons and daughters upon their mother's death. William also gave some additional instruction about the slaves:  "regarding the negros comfort and well being it is further my will that the negros belonging to me be kept in the family as long as they behave well and if any should become refractory and ungovernable, then it shall be the duty of my executors to hire such refractory slaves for the best price that can be had until they make amends."

At this point, I can hardly bear to continue this research because of the painful reality of white Gillespies directing so casually the fate of black Gillespies, who never chose the Gillespie name to begin with. But white William Gillespie gave us some important clues, the given names of his slaves. Do these names tie into the family tree of the black DNA match?

The black Gillespie family tree goes back to William Gillespie, born abt 1846 in KY; married to Lucy Jane, and by 1870 (post Civil War) appeared living in Mill Springs. In 1880, his children included Mary C., Rebecky J., Marthy T., Lueverney, Eddy J., and William P.  Lucy appeared in 1900 as a widow with two children: Perry, age 20, and Otho, age 18.  Lucy was last enumerated in 1910 at the age of 72 living with two sons, Perry W., 32, and Issac O, 23, and two grandsons, Ira M., 7, and Odis, 4.

Here's what I think. Given the names that appear in the black Gillespie family group, I believe the name patterns are repetitions from the slaves named in white William Gillespie's will in 1855:  Perry, Rebecca, Isaac, and William. If this is true, the child slave named William, the one recorded in white William Gillespie's 1855 will, was the same black man named William Gillespie who was free after the Civil War and then started his family with Lucy Jane.

Can we back this idea up with evidence?
  • The 1850 Slave Schedule for white William Gillespie does not show a male slave who would have been the right age to be black William Gillespie, and yet by 1855, white William Gillespie recorded a slave child, William.  Here's how I think that happened.  Remember James Cowan, father of William's wife, Nancy Cowan?  The 1850 census showed that Cowan had 11 slaves, one including a male around the age of 5 -- just the age of the slave William we are looking for. Cowan's will specified that his slaves should go to his wife, and after her death to his sons-in-law James R. Wilhite and William Gillespie. I contend that white William Gillespie probably inherited the slave child named William from the Cowan family.
  • The 1860 Slave Schedule for white Nancy Gillespie (widow of William) recorded 9 slaves, including one male, 15, mulatto. I contend this might have been black William Gillespie.
Oh, but there is still more. After April, 1864, African American soldiers were recruited and about 24,000 black Kentuckians joined the fight for their freedom.  I found documentation dated 1 Aug 1864, showing one William Gillespie, age 20, black, farmer born in Wayne, KY enlisted for 3 years. In the remarks we see "Owner Billy Gillespie." This black William Gillespie served the duration of the Civil War in the 6th US Colored Cavalry.  There is also an index entry for a pension application made by Lucy Gillespie for a William Gillespie of the 6th USCC. That William Gillespie was declared an invalid in 1891 (which is maybe why he was not enumerated in 1900), and Lucy was noted as a widow on 8 May 1906. Thus ended the life of a remarkable man named William Gillespie who had been born into slavery, and was known by an owner's name. But no matter the origin of his name, black William Gillespie joined the ranks of those fighting for freedom, which he ultimately gained and independently lived for another 40 years.

Summarizing this story does not provide half the justice due to the black Gillespies, nor does it answer all the questions. Even if the white Gillespies inherited the black Gillespies as slaves from the Cowans, where did the slaves come from originally? Who were their families and what were their stories? Is it still possible to find out? And what about Billy Gillespie, the owner who let black William Gillespie enlist to fight for the Union?  As far as I can tell, Billy must have been the son of white William and Nancy Gillespie, William K. Gillespie, 1844-1905. But it's still hard to piece this puzzle together. White William was about the same age as black William. And certainly Nancy was still alive in 1864, and I'm not sure that William K. at age 19 or 20 would have been able to authorize the enlistment of black William, especially given that there was no signature of the owner on the enlistment papers. I haven't found any evidence that the white Gillespies served for the militia of either side, so we don't know where they stood. Were white William and black William friends, having grown up together? Or did white William enlist black William for manumission and thus expect some compensation for black William's service? Or maybe black William just ran away to join the Union army. So many questions about what really happened.

And then there's the slight DNA match between the black Gillespie family and mine. Whatever that means, surely it includes my own desire to atone for the captivity and degradation and violence forced upon generations of black Americans, then and now. Most importantly for today, Juneteenth, I write to raise my voice in a flawed and still struggling America to honor the memory of all our ancestors and to strive for the continuing realization of what it truly means, freedom for all.

NOTE:  See also my related research on Mixed Race DNA matches.

Wednesday, May 13, 2020

Sweet Spot

I've been taking a bit of break from my NY Gillespy mapping project, but there's never a shortage of side topics to get my curiosity. Because the last place I studied was Walkill Precinct, I was reminded of a long-time mystery Gillespie, Robert Gillespie 1774-1857 who married Lea Crans. So I decided to reacquaint myself with Robert's life, and see if there's anything new to add to his story. You know, just for fun.

Who knew that following the genealogy trail to Susquehanna County, PA could be so much fun? There I found a deed between Robert's grandson, Joseph W. Gillespie, and Gilbert O. Sweet for one acre in Gibson, PA. Curiously, Gibson was the place where Almon C. Sweet lived with his wife, Caroline Foster. Caroline Foster was the daughter of Susanna Gillespie, ~1786-1829, who was in turn the daughter of James Gillespie and Mary Brown Bannerman, who in turn we can associate with the Rensselaer Gillespie family group. Much of my recent research has been devoted to the question of whether the Rensselaer Gillespies were connected to the Ulster/Orange Gillespies, as I believe they were. Now this little side trip to Susquehanna, PA gives us even more insight into all the possible connections.

All of which comes from recognizing the SWEET surname, (were their ancestors confectioners?), which in turn lead to another rather interesting discovery. Harford, Susquehanna, PA was originally a settlement called Nine Partners, Luzerne, PA. The settlers were nine families from Attleboro, Massachusetts, which seems to be the place of origin of the Sweet families I've been studying. One Sweet family intermarried with another Attleboro family: FOSTER -- the very same Foster family to which John Foster was directly related -- John Foster having been the husband of Susanna Gillespie and the father of Caroline Foster who ended up as the wife of Almon C. Sweet.  Read here for more details of my findings.

The complexity of this situation with all the nuances of myriad genealogical interconnections is almost beautiful. It could be that, like the Gillespies, seemingly, everybody was somehow related to everybody else. How sweet it was, is, and shall ever be.

Sunday, April 26, 2020

Stewart State Forest

According to Explore-Hudson-Valley.com, the 6700 acres of Stewart State Forest was set aside as a buffer zone for an expanded Stewart International Airport just west of downtown Newburgh, NY. The idea was to insulate the noise coming from what was then expected to become NYC's fourth major airport.

Aside from the interesting history of the airport, the Stewart State Forest is now a vast preserve for naturalists and outdoor recreation that is somewhat unique in the northeast. Besides the abundance of flora and fauna, there are also the old farmlands and wide gravel roads of yesteryear. These lands were once occupied by our ancestors, including Gillespys.
  • Matthew Gillespy, 1740-1797, had married Jane Neely in 1766, and they had made an agreement with Jane's father, James Neely Sr., to help care for the elderly parents and the Neely farm in New Windsor. The farm of James Neely was located on the north side of Little Britain Rd. (today Route 207) probably between Ridge Rd. and Giles Rd. Matthew lived there probably as early as 1781 (he was an Assessor in New Windsor), and he continued to live there after his wife's death in 1788. The 1790 census shows that Matthew was living near to Henry McNeely, thought to have been a brother of James Neely Sr. Matthew remarried around 1791 and moved to NYC where he became a grocer. Matthew died in 1797 and a subsequent legal dispute involving the Neely farm was eventually decided by the NY Supreme Court in 1814. 
  • James Gillespy, (dates uncertain, but I'm speculating ~1739-1810), sold his lands near Gillespie Street south of Pine Bush in 1788 and together with his wife, Mary, subsequently bought 50 acres in Little Britain. The land of James was part of the Andrew Johnson patent, and from the property description, it was also north of Little Britain Road, probably between Ridge Rd. and Maple Ave. -- maybe along a dirt road today called Scofield Lane Trail Orange. I calculate that James and Matthew lived just over 2 miles apart. We can see from the 1790 census that James' neighbors included the names of many officers in New York's Revolutionary military command: Belknap, Moffat, Dubois, Burnet, Scott, Humphrey, Alexander Denniston, General James Clinton, and the widow of Col. James McClaughry. There is, in fact, a historical marker at the corner of the Route 207 and Beattie Rd. to mark the one-time residence of James Clinton. But even though surrounded by NY's military elite, James Gillespy had to mortgage his Little Britain property in 1791, which was later paid in 1794 by John McMickle. We must assume that James Gillespy had moved on by that time.
Still in all, I think we're looking at the heart of some important connections. According to New York Colonial Muster Rolls 1664-1775, Volume 2, pp 736-737, in 1763, Capt. James Clinton's company was enlisted to guard the western frontiers of Ulster and Orange counties; Lieutenants included William Stewart, Alexander Denniston, Matthew Smedes, and James McNeal (likely Neely). Among those enlisted were James Gillespy, age 24 (b abt 1739), born in Ireland, came from Capt. Neely's militia. In the same company was Samuel Gillespy, age 19 (b 1744), born in Ulster, came from Capt. Graham's militia.

What is all this telling us about our Gillespys? We know that Samuel Gillespy and Matthew Gillespy were brothers (by Samuel's will), and I'm building the case that this James Gillespy was also a brother. I would love to wander the woods and meadows of Stewart State Forest to see if the winds of history have some long forgotten tales to tell about this Gillespy family.

Friday, April 24, 2020

Gillespie Street in Pine Bush

In my recent quest to map Gillespie locations in New York, I finally came to the hamlet of Pine Bush, found in the town of Crawford. I personally visited Pine Bush in 2012, and even stopped in at the town library, just to say that I did. But what I really needed then was a tour guide because I couldn't fully appreciate where I was at the time. Now after mapping the homestead of Samuel Gillespy on the eastern outskirts of Pine Bush, I realize this locale was the home for several generations of Samuel's descendants.

But were Samuel's descendants the only ones to live in and around Pine Bush? We know now that Capt. John Gillespy and his grist mill were only 5 miles outside of town on the Dwaar Kill. But John sold his properties outside the Pine Bush area in 1785 and moved his family to New Windsor, and it doesn't appear that any from his family remained in Pine Bush. Did any other Gillespies spend time in Pine Bush? I contend there was at least one other, James Gillespy. Upon mapping the location of James' property as described in 1788, it was interesting to see from a modern satellite map that a corner of the property is bordered today by Route 48 on the south and Gillespie St. on the east, and 2.5 miles east of Burlingham in Mamakating Precinct where I recently discovered other Gillespy properties. I'm obviously still catching up to what other Gillespie researchers already know about these locales, but learning is half the fun.  You can read more about finding Gillespie Street here.

Now that I am getting my bearings, I think of a line from a Seamus Heaney poem:

If self is a location, so is love: 
Bearings taken, markings, cardinal points, Options, obstinacies, dug heels and distance, 
Here and there and now and then, a stance.

Sunday, April 12, 2020

Deed Mapping

This past week, I've been following the Gillespy trail using two of my favorite sources, historical maps and old deeds. These sources often contain genealogy surprises, but they also teach us alot about compass bearings and distances measured by chain lengths. (See Life of a 1700's Surveyor for some great details.) Translating those old property descriptions onto Google Earth satellite maps could and does occupy me happily for days. Given that I am "sheltered in place" during the COVID-19 pandemic, it's a good use of my time.

This time around, my deed-digging lead me to recognize property that was near to James Gillespy who, in 1770, sold his Shawangunk property on the west side of the Walkill River. That lead to learning more about the Gerarrd Beekman Patent of 3000 acres where the Gillespy land was located. That lead to reviewing the property descriptions of the Gillespys in that patent, where I soon realized a mistake made in my earlier reading of them. I love finding my own mistakes and correcting them because that almost always explains something I couldn't quite understand before. See my latest article about Gillespy and Hunter homesteads in Shawangunk.

Oh, but once on a roll with maps and deeds, why not go on? My next task was to study more closely the deeds of Capt. John Gillespy. That lead to learning about the 10,000-acre Schuyler Patent to the west and south of the Shawangunk precinct, land located in the precinct of Walkill-then Hanover-then Montgomery. In the end, we discover that Capt. John resided on the Walkill/Hanover/Montgomery side, but his grist mill was just across the precinct line in Shawangunk on the farm of James Hunter. See my other latest article about Capt. John Gillespy living on the line.

So all in all, it's been a good week for understanding precisely where some Gillespy characters lived. I think the key to understanding relationships is to understand individuals. One by one, we are getting to know the Gillespy characters of early Ulster/Orange, NY. Eventually, I believe their relationships to each other, and to us, will reveal themselves.

And so ends my genealogy report on Easter Sunday 2020 when a spring snowstorm is blanketing Colorado as I write. It seems fitting that my world should be under a snowy hush given that, because of COVID-19, there was no sunrise service up on Flagstaff mountain this morning, there are no easter lillies being delivered, no easter egg hunts around the neighborhood, no gatherings of scattered family and friends except via Zoom. But then I realize that our Gillespy ancestors were also likely in their homes on their Easter Sunday. It seems most of the early colonists did not celebrate holidays, especially this one, in the way we do today. They were in their homes, resting and reflecting on a Sunday. Just as we are doing now.

Saturday, April 4, 2020

Case Sensitive

Last fall, I ran across reference to a complicated legal case involving two Gillespy brothers which was heard by the NY Supreme Court in 1814. The case report stated specific Gillespy family relationships, i.e., who married whom, and names of children, which is information most often received by a genealogist as a dream come true. But as I have continued piecing together the Gillespy family groups of early Ulster/Orange, NY, the genealogical details from that NY Supreme Court case just don't fit with other evidence, which is not to say that I haven't really been trying to MAKE them fit. For Pete's Sake, the source is a case report from the NY Supreme Court, so it must be right! But alas, it would seem that every source, every single one, must be critically examined and corroborated. I think this particular case report was probably mistaken in some of the key details pertaining to Gillespy relationships. You can read about my analysis here.

Meanwhile, the best way to really corroborate any of the details in the NY Supreme Court case report is to find the minutes pertaining to the Gillespy case from the lower courts. This Gillespy case was apparently heard several times before reaching the NY Supreme Court - in the Ulster County Court of Common Pleas as well as the Orange County Circuit Court, and maybe others. But locating those records is easier said than done, especially knowing that other interested researchers have tried with determination and failed to locate these records. But are the negative search results because the records no longer exist, or because the records are simply not indexed (which effectively hinders any search), and/or they have been mislabeled or misfiled and/or they have been restrictively stored some place that is physically and/or financially inaccessible to the public? I'd love to hear from anybody who has experience or advise about successfully locating early (pre-1800) court records in Ulster or Orange counties, NY.

At this point, I'm going to give a plug to support any genealogical or historical society whose volunteers are attempting to index records and make those indices available online. Even better, support Reclaim The Records. This organization has made phenomenal progress, especially in New York, using the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) to see that public records are released to the public domain. The job of discovering and untangling our family history should not be hampered by government restrictions. My two cents.

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Shawangunk Neighbors

Since the discovery of the 1770 deed of Shawangunk property from James Gillespy to Matthew Bevier Jr., I thought it would be productive to get more familiar with the Gillespy neighbors. Me and my bright ideas. The work is interesting and mind-numbing at the same time! Nevertheless, here is my research report, which is my best attempt to sort through the myriad details looking for Gillespy connections. Some of the highlights include:
  • mention of relatives in ARMAGH (KAIN)
  • James Gillespy as a deed witness (KAIN)
  • William, Matthew, and Mary Gillespy as will witnesses (ROOSA)
  • mention of Matthew Gillespie as a former landowner  (ROOSA)
  • mention of Ann Gillespie daughter of Matthew Gillespie, deceased (GRAHAM)
From the looks of things, after selling the Shawangunk property James Gillespy moved down into the Hanover Precinct (what became the town of Montgomery). I guess I'll be meeting the neighbors in Hanover next....

Tuesday, February 4, 2020

*Hunter Gathering*

The next phase of my research involves investigating more about associated families to the early NY Gillespys, specifically those of the surname HUNTER and WILKIN(S). Each of these associated family groups have their own rich and complicated history, so I'm prepared for this study to take awhile. As true as that is to say, today a rather startling realization popped out which deserves making note.

First, to give a little context. The Hunter family history tells us that Robert Hunter I came to America about 1727 from Northern Ireland with three sons: Archibald, James, and Robert. The Hunters settled in Shawangunk, and their names can be found among those who served in the 1738 Walkill militia. As the story goes, the Hunters also brought a couple of Gillespys with them from Northern Ireland, specifically Samuel (Sr.) and Elizabeth. We've not yet found any record of Samuel Gillespy Sr, and supposedly Elizabeth Gillespy (1715-1756) married Robert Hunter Jr. (1714-1776). To be honest, I haven't yet found an actual record of Elizabeth Gillespy Hunter either, but let's just say she did exist, and she had six children before her death. One of those children, Eliza Lily Hunter (1754-1828) married her first cousin, James Hunter (son of James, son of Robert I). I know I know, eyes are rolling, but bear with me.

Eliza Lily Hunter, daugther of Elizabeth Gillespie Hunter, had several children with James Hunter, the youngest of whom was James I. Hunter 1783-1863. He married Mahitable Haines and they lived in Montgomery, Orange, NY until the time his mother, Eliza Lily, died in 1828. Then James and his family moved. He moved west. Let's say 600+ miles west, possibly by land or possibly by way of the Erie Canal and then across Lake Erie. Destination? Bloomfield, Oakland, Michigan! Anybody who has followed this blog might remember that all my beginning posts pertained to Bloomfield and the discovery of Gillespie-Greer relations who tie directly into my family tree!

James I. Hunter purchased two 80-acre land patents in Bloomfield in 1831. The 1840 census shows us that his neighbors were Hiram H, William G, and Charles Hunter (James' sons), William Kidd, William Greer, and Henry Sloat. In the same census of the same place, we find the list of my family: Joseph, John, James, Thomas, and Robert Greer, George Slater, Charles Lemon, Elizabeth Gordon (Gillespie), and Thomas Gillespie. I estimate the distance between the Greer and Hunter farms to have been under three miles. It could be coincidence. Or not.

For fun, I checked my DNA matches for Hunter. And lo. Again, something small, 8cM across 1 segment for a 5th-8th cousin match, a direct descendant of James I. Hunter, and thus also, presumably, Elizabeth Gillespie 1715-1756.

So here we have yet another small link between our Michigan Gillespie-Greer families and the Gillespy families of early New York. But we're still fishing for the connection. When I lay it out with index cards on the table, I can speculate that James I. Hunter, Nancy Greer, Jane Greer, and Elizabeth Gillespie were all second cousins. Going up the line, I think that means that Elizabeth Gillespie Hunter (1715-1756) left behind a brother in Northern Ireland, one who was the father of our progenitor John Gillspie (b abt 1758), who in turn had children by his first marriage, Nancy, Jane, and Elizabeth, all who emigrated to NY before the War of 1812.

Clearly this post is about evidence that is highly speculative, so this is not a "dicovery," per se. But wherever we have found the name of Elizabeth Gillespie, we have learned more about our family history than we could have dreamed about.

Wednesday, January 22, 2020

New Evidence

there she blows - Wiktionary
(nautical) The traditional hail of the lookout in a whaler (whaling ship) when sighting the spouting water thrown up by a whale surfacing.

If I had been a whaler rather a genealogist, first I would be seasick, then I would be saying There She Blows! Genealogy is about sailing on the surface of a vast underworld of ancestors. That these ancestors exist(ed) below the surface is not a question. The question is where to look for them, and how and when we might encounter them. As we start this new decade of 2020, the answer to the question is Maybe Here, Maybe Now.  There She Blows.

And when I say We in my blog posts, I am always referring to collaboration, either in the exploration for, the discovery of, and/or the analysis of genealogical evidence. My most recent collaborator has been one Doug Hart. His research into the Gillespie's of early Ulster/Orange (& surrounding areas) spans decades, and his documentation of it has resulted in a Compendium that he generated with a Typewriter (!) in the 1990s. A Compendium sounds a bit like my rookie attempt to catalog some NY Gillespie's in 2012. Compendium, Catalog. Catalog, Compendium. OK, a Compendium sounds more complete and it is. Doug deserves alot of credit for tracing and studying several NY Gillespie family groups, though long and tedious a task, with the belief that doing so could allow the story of previously obscured Gillespie's to surface. That I generally share this research approach with Doug and that we both seem committed to ongoing discussions of possibility and meaning with regard to Gillespie evidence, both old and new, surely makes us collaborators and me grateful.

All of which is a long introduction to reporting on Doug's recent discoveries of new evidence to add to our NY Gillespie research bucket. Here is a summary:
  • A 1770 deed of James Gillespy selling 129 acres of his land in Shawangunk to Matthew Beviers Jr. This document, a transcription, is one that Doug found long ago in his research, but which, at the time, could not be more fully understood. The transcription of the original deed is in itself an exquisite piece of work, giving clarity to the original language of the deed which not only mentions the names of James' wife, and also those of James' parents and when they might have died, but it also describes the exact property later sold in 1797 by William Gillespy Jr and his wife Martha to Matthew Gillespie previously of NYC and more recently of Montgomery. We are in the process of locating the original deed, which when located, will be a wonder to behold, I have no doubt.
  • A database of Colden Store records where many Gillespie's are mentioned, some mentioning genealogical relationship, and some involving names that imply closer relationship (neighbor, and/or in-law?) -- specifically Hunter and Kain, and more indirectly, Graham. 
  • A transcription of marriage records of the First Presbyterian Church of Troy showing three Gillespie marriages. The marriage catching our attention now is that of Andrew Graham and Jane Gillespie, married in 1797 in Lansingburgh, a place central to our current research exploring links between Ulster and Rensselaer Gillespie's.
To continue the oceanic analogy started in this post, sometimes evidence comes in waves splashing over the deck. The waves are unpredictable and forceful in nature; they can wreck what was once there, and often they leave behind things that are long forgotten or else inexplicable. In this case, all we know with certainty is that the deck is still wet and littered with fragments. Doug and I are in the process of analyzing this new evidence and how it applies to our growing pile of evidence and analysis from the last several months (see my Research Library for 2019 articles). There is a sense that we are inching closer to something of greater import; it could be a whale of a story. Stay tuned.

*Tin Anniversary*

I am having an anniversary of sorts. It's been ten years now since I started working on genealogy "seriously," and nearly that long since I decided to try blogging. From its start, this blog was meant to report Forward Progress on MY Gillespies, which is to say, progress that relates solely to those descendants of John Gillespie and Jane Woods of County Armagh, Northern Ireland. Period. There are innumerable other Gillespies in the world, but it has not been my purpose to research them nor to report on them here even if I were privately interested. It has been a selfishly narrow decision to make, and one that I think our previous family historian, Aunt Edith, also had to make. We have only so much time given to us, and so how shall we spend it? Doing what we think matters most in the long run.

Now, ten years later, I feel this policy of My-Gillespies-Only needs some amending. The simple truth is that we don't know what we don't know, and to overcome that, it seems to me, I have to be willing to open more doors to see what's on the other side. By widening the net, purposefully, I increase the chances of furthering what matters most. And what is that? In my lifetime, I would like to find the Gillespie connection back to Scotland. I know it's there, we all do. But I want to book my flight to Glasgow knowing the names of the ancestors who started this story. I have hope. I think there's still time.

With that said, I made a more conscious choice last fall to start wandering off the beaten path of my Gillespie research. Following small DNA matches that appear to connect me and others of my known relations back to New York, I've started to more fully engage in understanding exactly who were the Gillespie family groups of early Ulster/ Orange/ Dutchess counties. My only goal has become this: to learn more even if the work never ties back to MY Gillespies directly. By finding a balance between keeping my questions mentally focused and my research disciplined, and allowing room for curiosity, instinct, and even accidental insights, I believe it's still possible to discover more and move our collective understanding forward.

From here on, the posts you read on this blog may not apply directly to MY Gillespies. In the title of each forthcoming blog post, I will somewhere embed an asterisk (*) if the information being posted is something only a direct cousin to My Gillespies would want to read. Otherwise, expect my posts to cover my thoughts on various research discoveries as they pertain to the surname Gillespie, even if the discoveries, for now, seem irrelevant to my immediate family. As with the world in general, it becomes increasingly more obvious to me that we are all connected somehow. By shining a curious and insistent light on other early Gillespie families, we might yet find our way back to Glasgow.

Monday, December 9, 2019

The Road to Sterling

If you've been following my research journeys this fall, you know that I have taken an interest in identifying Gillespie family groups in early Ulster/ Orange, NY by way of bounty lands that were delivered to the heirs of soldiers who died in the Revolution. The story that came out of the Marcellus bounty land was enough to inspire me to carry on with the next task of identifying the heirs of Robert Gillespie. But the road to Sterling has been more bumpy.

At this point in my genealogy life, I'm usually pretty good at figuring out how county lines changed over time, and where I need to be looking for records. But the more I tried to dig into Sterling, the more empty the results. The Gillespie family went through the NY State Legislature to get this Sterling property -- what happened to it? In Stuck Times like these, I have to pause and wonder What Am I Missing? What Don't I Know? In terms of New York counties as pertains to the Central Military Tract, I know I don't know alot. Time to ask for help.

Let me here express my humble thanks to all those who attempt to share what they know about complicated genealogical questions, and to one particular volunteer at the Cayuga County NYGenWeb Project.  Recently, complete strangers have re-energized my research with their mutual curiosity and willingness to share what they know.  I am certainly not the only one who believes in the importance of history and getting it right.  Thank you.

With that said, here is the helpful reply that I received to my inquiry about where to look for land records pertaining to Sterling Lot 51.  I find this explanation infinitely more clear than anything I have read on the internet:

Be aware that your Sterling Lot 51 land records research may involve looking within 2 or 3 NY counties. The original Military Tract Township of Sterling NY was established & surveyed into lots in circa 1794-1795.  Onondaga County NY was formed from Herkimer County in March 1794. Thus, lot 51 in the Military Tract Township of Sterling was originally part of Onondaga County NY. Cayuga County NY was formed from part of Onondaga County in March 1799. Then in March 1804, the west portion of Cayuga County (including the west half of the original Township of Sterling with Lot 51) became part of Seneca County NY.  A part of Seneca County (Including the west half of Sterling Township with Lot 51) was taken off to become part of Wayne County NY in 1823.  

Consequently, Lot 51 in the original Military Tract Township of Sterling was likely only considered part of Cayuga County from 1799 to 1804. From about 1804 to 1823, Lot 51 in the original Military Tract Township of Sterling was probably considered part of Seneca County NY.  Then after 1823, Sterling M/T Township Lot 51 was part of Wayne County NY. To further complicate things, the west half of the original M/T Tract Township of Sterling was renamed a few times between 1794-1823. I'm not sure of the exact dates... But it looks like the west portion of Sterling Township became known as part of the Town of Junius in Seneca County and then later became known as the Town of Wolcott in Seneca & later Wayne County. Today, Lot 51 in the original Military Tract Township of Sterling is NOW located within the Town of Wolcott in Wayne County NY.  

So Holy Cow. Based on the detailed knowledge of my helpful expert, Sterling would have been part of Seneca county in 1807. And LO! There we find a deed from William Gillespie of Newburgh, Orange, NY selling his 1/4th interest in Sterling Lot #51. The deed recites that this land was the patent granted to the representatives of Robert Gillespie, deceased. This much alone is enough to make me leap from my chair with joy. It all but confirms my working theory that the Ulster Gillespie brothers, namely William, Samuel, and Matthew, were also brothers of Robert who died after being captured by the British in 1777. But if the Sterling land was being sold in undivided fourths, and we now have William and by association Samuel, and Matthew -- who was the fourth? Based on the names in the list of Robert's representatives, I submit the fourth heir was a man named James Gillespie - the name of a man, indeed that of several men I have been spending inordinate amounts of time researching.

But this particular road to Sterling contains a bonus surprise. William Gillespie sold his part of the Sterling land for $1 to Andrew Gillespie of Lansingburgh, Rensselaer, NY, and Andrew and wife Sally subsequently sold it for $261 to Josiah Shippey of NYC. Why should we care about Andrew Gillespie? Because he also served in the Revolution, and in his pension application, he reported that he was born in Shawangunk, Ulster, NY in 1763. And because the only person to vouch for him was Matthew Gillespie of Lansingburgh who had known Andrew for over 60 years (yes, probably Andrew's brother). And because we have a collection of indirect evidence strongly suggesting that the father of Andrew and Matthew Gillespie may have been one James Gillespie.  

And so, this particular research quest to find Gillespie's in Sterling, Cayuga, NY ends in Wolcott, Wayne, NY where it appears, so far, that no Gillespie ever took residence.  But the Pay Dirt on this one is bigger than that.  The bounty land records have given us a much broader understanding of the Ulster/Orange Gillespie family group. Andrew Gillespie was not only a Revolutionary veteran, he was also a skipper on the Hudson, as were the men believed to be his brothers, Matthew and Joseph, and some of their sons after that.  These Gillespie's lived in Troy and Albany and New York City, that we know of, in the years leading to the War of 1812.  Their stories and their connection to the Ulster/Orange Gillespie's seem more clear by the day.  The more we learn, the richer the Gillespie family history becomes.

And finally, let us not forget Robert Gillespie, the one who lost his life in what were surely inhumane prison conditions in 1777.  Thirty years after his death, Robert's family certainly remembered him on the road to Sterling, even without knowing that the struggle to be free from the British was still not over. Freedom is never free. I dedicate this post gratefully to their memory, the resisters, the fallen, the survivors, one and all.


Wednesday, October 23, 2019

NY Bounty Lands

I've lately been working on a study of men named James Gillespy/Gillespie in early Ulster/Orange counties, New York.  Even though at this point, I am not looking for a particular connection to the James Gillespie who appeared with my Michigan pioneers in 1850 Bloomfield, Oakland, MI, I became curious about the men named James Gillespy/Gillespie who served in the American Revolution. It turns out there was much to learn, in particular from the bounty lands that were awarded to Gillespie's in 1790:
  • James Gillespy, NY. 4th NY Reg under Walker, listed among the dead.  Sep 1790, 500 acres to heirs.  This land was in Marcellus in Onondaga county, lot #34. The patent was delivered 7 Jul 1790 to C.C. Schoonmaker for W. Gillaspy, adm.  Given that C. C. Schoonmaker was from the Shawangunk area, W. Gillsapy was probably William Gillespy 1737-1813 who was enumerated in Shawangunk in 1790.
  • Robert Gillespie. 16 Aug 1807.  200 Acres to Gillespie representatives James, Samuel, William, John, Barbara, Matthew, Jane, Ann, Polly, Olive, Burr, and James Gillespie Jr.  This land was in Sterling, Cayuga county, lot #51.
I followed up by checking on deeds in Onondaga and Cayuga counties, and found two Onondaga deeds selling the land of James Gillespie in Marcellus. These deeds show that the property was divided in fifths, and four Gillespie's were named:  John (wife Sarah), Margaret, Elizabeth (Wallace), and Hanna (Lebolt), all of Ulster or Orange counties, NY. David Gillespie appeared in Marcellus starting in 1801 (tax lists), so I have to presume that he was the fifth heir of James. Given my understanding of who was considered next of kin when someone died intestate, I believe that John and David were brothers of James, Margaret could have been an unmarried sister, and Elizabeth and Hanna were likely daughters of another Gillespie sibling who had died before 1790 (I guess George). See my article for more details.

That leaves the men named James listed as heirs of the bounty land of Robert Gillespie who served in the 5th NY Regiment and died after being captured at Ft. Montgomery in 1777. More research is in process which seems to indicate that Robert's heirs also tie back to Ulster and Orange counties, New York. So much to untangle, and so much to learn, not the least of which is the discovery that bounty land records are a very valuable source of genealogical information!

UPDATE 12/5/2019:  We have an update pertaining to the William Gillespie who was administrator of the bounty land of James Gillespie who served with the NY 4th Regiment.  It turns out that he too was awarded bounty land in Marcellus.  Read all about it.

Friday, October 11, 2019

Welcome to Mamakating

Mamekoting was one of the Hudson Valley native American tribes, which is today the name of a town in Sullivan County, NY, and uses the spelling Mamakating, pronounced "ma-MA-ka-TING".

So now we have another fun-to-pronounce place to add to our family geography, one that is a mere 20 miles from another fun-to-pronounce Gillespie location, Shawangunk.  I stumbled upon Mamakating by tracing Abraham Gillespie who had some land in Mamakating when the town was in Sullivan county. But Sullivan county was not formed until 1809, and so where was Mamakating before that?  Ulster.

In any case, Mamakating Precinct is one place where the 1775 Articles of Allegiance, also called the Revolutionary Pledge, have survived. Four Gillespy names appeared on that list:  John, James, David, and George.  Along with records showing that the Fifth Hanover Company in 1775 had officers Capt. John Gillespie and Ensign Samuel Gillespie, I think we have a good picture of the Gillespie families with strong roots in the Ulster area.  More research is upcoming!

Meanwhile, here is a new article relating more details about my initial research in Sullivan county.

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

John Gillespy of Shawangunk

In my periodic review of records and DNA matches, I found one very remote match to me and two other of our elder Gillespie relations. This DNA match has a direct ancestor named Martha Jane Gillespie, 1832-1908, daughter of John Gillespie and Maria Klyne, wife of Andrew J Evans. These families lived in the Shawangunk area of Ulster county, which is the general area of New York where our early Gillespie and Greer families lived.

This new John Gillespy deserves some attention. He was born in Orange County around 1803, which means that his family was in America before our relations came around 1812. Who was he? Here is my latest research exploring that question.

It's exciting to think that we have finally found some connection between my Michigan Gillespie family and the Samuel Gillespy families of pre-Revolutionary New York. It means that Michigan Gillespie's are remotely related to all those early New York Gillespy's. The evidence of that connection, however, still only stems from a fairly trivial DNA match. All of this learning about the family group of John Gillespy of Shawangunk still provides no documented tie to the Gillespie's who migrated to Michigan in the 1830s. But, I feel we're getting closer. The better we understand each Gillespy family group, the more likely it is that more connections will surface. Closer and closer.